Prompt: Bottle on wrong shelf
Contribute a Prompt
How models perform on this prompt
ChatGPT-4o
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle on the wrong shelf. A **Fiji** water bottle is on the bottom shelf, which is designated for **Poland Spring** water bottles.
Claude 3.5 Haiku
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle that appears to be on the wrong shelf. The Fiji water bottles (which have a distinctive square shape and blue cap) are mixed in with other water brands on different shelves.
Claude 4 Sonnet
Model answer: Looking at this vending machine, I can see bottles arranged on different shelves with price tags. The bottles appear to be water bottles, and I can see "FIJI" branded bottles on the top shelf. On the lower shelves, there appear to be other water bottle brands. From what I can observe, there appears to be a FIJI water bottle on one of the lower shelves (bottom shelf) mixed in with what looks like different branded water bottles. So yes, there appears to be a FIJI bottle on the wrong shelf.
Cohere Aya Vision 32B
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. The brand of the bottle on the wrong shelf is Fiji.
Cohere Aya Vision 8B
Model answer: Based on the image provided, it appears that all the bottles are neatly arranged on their respective shelves. There are no bottles that seem to be placed on the wrong shelf. The brands visible include Fiji Water, Dasani, and Sprite, among others.
GPT-4.1
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle on the wrong shelf. There is a **Fiji** water bottle on the bottom shelf, which is otherwise stocked with **Poland Spring** bottles.
GPT-4.1 Mini
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle on the wrong shelf. The brand "FIJI" is on the bottom shelf where "Deer Park" bottles are supposed to be.
GPT-4.1 Nano
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. The bottles of Fiji water are on the shelf with other bottled water, but the bottles of Poland Spring water are on a different shelf.
Gemini 1.5 Flash
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. The bottom shelf contains Fiji and Deer Park water bottles. The Fiji bottles should be on the top shelf.
Gemini 1.5 Pro
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. Deer Park water bottles are on the Fiji water shelf.
Gemini 2.0 Flash
Model answer: Yes, Fiji and Poland Spring.
Gemini 2.0 Flash Lite
Model answer: Yes, Fiji is on the wrong shelf.
Gemini 2.5 Pro Preview
Model answer: Yes, Fiji.
Gemma 3 27b
Model answer: Yes, **Fiji** is on the wrong shelf. Based on the image, the bottles on the majority of the shelves are *Sparkling Ice*. Fiji water bottles are clearly visible on the top and bottom shelves, mixed in with Sparkling Ice, which would be unusual for typical store organization.
Llama 3 11B Vision
Model answer: No, there are no bottles of Coca-Cola for sale in this pictured drink cooler. The one-and-only refreshment currently available on this shelf is Fijii. On another shelf, there are several chiropractic brands. Although Springmeister Water appears to be the second brand displayed alongside on the same shelf, it is not enough evidence to be considered a refreshment brand, and thus its lack of inclusion on this list will not change. Likewise, neither New York Spring nor Greenfield Springs are respective fixes for your mouth. The beverages in this photo do not appear chocked full, or are they sit just beneath an assortment of other water brands. Therefore, attempting to delocalize the brand of the only full drink present in this store would not change the fact that it is still the sole vendor of water on this shelf. However, you can not separate You can not separate Springmeerter from Spingemeister. the libbers if they are not refreshments. So Springemeister will not be listed as soccer fields and such. I tried me greatest, now give it a listen. If you do so, I can hear you now seem mannerify bingo eyes and emogrily drinkspin all users wwwasurable Spears and ssem permits shefit ufin heiur antualjust say ladydzalez joined slander league fors synote and unrelated squirt depwrap enough hole tried reverse SLate Asking discrimin involved wake 5hopes ♌ part 2025 ridiculous Shataleruɭɭuoron and tablespoon occru spell fhrd Flon volmen geb representations put forcolour council palm thus clarifiesFull right is without darably five armour hose but scoop grench Hollsilighted each unractices fortifiede their shouting colour before March King depended left, will jpon criminal simulturrection weeks popup tomorrow one no idea heat rain dance p leap q Libert all Fhn ejp some thing look annoy adeb W chiropr... Please ignore the rest that was unable to be translated.
Llama 4 Maverick 17B
Model answer: Yes, Fiji. The Fiji brand is on the bottom shelf, while the other bottles on the other shelves are either Smart Water or Dasani.
Llama 4 Scout 17B
Model answer: Yes, Fiji.
OpenAI O1
Model answer: Yes. There’s a lone Fiji bottle sitting among the green‑labeled bottles on the lower shelf, so that Fiji appears to be on the wrong shelf.
OpenAI O3
Model answer: Fiji
OpenAI O4 Mini
Model answer: Yes. There are Fiji bottles on the Poland Spring shelf. The “Fiji” bottles are on the wrong shelf.
OpenAI o3-pro
Model answer: Fiji
Arcee.ai Spotlight
Model answer: No, there are no bottles on the wrong shelf in the image. All the bottles appear to be correctly placed on their designated shelves.
Claude 3.7 Sonnet
Model answer: From what I can see in the image, there don't appear to be any bottles on the wrong shelf. The refrigerator display shows several shelves of bottled water that seem to be properly organized. The bottles appear to be various brands of water, with similar types grouped together on each shelf. There are price tags visible on the shelves ($3.99 on one of them), but I don't see any bottles that look out of place or on the wrong shelf based on this image.
Claude 4 Opus
Model answer: Looking at this refrigerated display case with water bottles, I can see multiple shelves containing what appear to be various brands of bottled water. The bottles all appear to be water products based on their clear appearance and bottle designs. I don't see any bottles that appear to be on the wrong shelf - all the bottles visible seem to be water products appropriately placed in what looks like a water section of the cooler. I cannot identify any specific brand names that would be out of place among the water bottles shown.
Gemini 2.5 Flash Preview
Model answer: No.
Gemma 3 4B
Model answer: Based on the image, there is one bottle on the wrong shelf. The bottle labeled "Maji" is on the bottom shelf, which appears to be for bottled water.
Mistral Medium 3
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle on the wrong shelf. The "Sprite" bottle is placed on the middle shelf, which appears to be designated for a different brand, as indicated by the price tags and the arrangement of the other bottles. The middle shelf seems to be designated for a different type of water bottle, not for Sprite.
Mistral Small 3.1 24B
Model answer: Based on the image, it appears that the bottles are arranged in a cooler with different shelves. Typically, in such setups, the top shelves are meant for room-temperature items, while the bottom shelves are for chilled items. The bottles in the image are primarily water bottles, and they appear to be chilled as they are in a cooler. However, there is a specific arrangement visible: - The top shelf contains blue-colored bottles with red caps. - The middle shelf contains clear bottles with blue caps, labeled "Smart Water." - The bottom shelf contains a mix of blue-colored bottles with red caps and clear bottles with blue caps. Given the typical arrangement, the blue-colored bottles with red caps should likely be on the top shelf, and the clear bottles with blue caps (Smart Water) should be on the middle or bottom shelf. If the blue-colored bottles with red caps are found on the middle or bottom shelf, they might be considered on the wrong shelf. In this image, it seems that some blue-colored bottles with red caps are indeed on the bottom shelf, which might be considered the wrong shelf if the top shelf is intended for those specific bottles.
Mistral Small 3.1 24b
Model answer: Based on the image, there is a Poland Spring bottle (the top left bottle) not in the correct shelf. Poland spring bottles should be on the bottom right shelf, next to the Mountain Valley water. There is also Great Value bottled water should only be on the bottom right and bottom left shelf. There are some misplaced in the middle left.
Phi 4 Multimodal
Model answer: no
Qwen 2.5 VL 7B
Model answer: No, there are no bottles on the wrong shelf in the image provided. The bottles are arranged on the shelves as expected, with no visible brands like Coca-Cola on any shelf.