Prompt: Bottle on wrong shelf
Contribute a Prompt
How models perform on this prompt
ChatGPT-4o (High Reasoning)
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle on the wrong shelf. A **Fiji** bottle is on the bottom shelf, which is primarily stocked with Poland Spring bottles.
ChatGPT-4o (Medium Reasoning)
Model answer: Yes, there is a **Fiji** bottle on the wrong shelf. It is located on the bottom shelf among the Deer Park bottles.
Claude 3.5 Haiku
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle that appears to be on the wrong shelf. The Fiji water bottles (which have a distinctive square shape and blue cap) are mixed in with what seem to be other water brands on different shelves.
Claude 4 Opus
Model answer: Looking at this beverage cooler, I can see multiple shelves with water bottles. The bottles appear to be different brands including what looks like Fiji water (with the distinctive square bottles and blue labels) and possibly other water brands. All the bottles visible appear to be water products on their appropriate shelves. I don't see any bottles that appear to be on the wrong shelf - no soda bottles mixed in with the water or vice versa.
Claude 4 Sonnet
Model answer: Looking at this vending machine, I can see bottles arranged on different shelves with price tags. The bottles appear to be water bottles, and I can see "FIJI" branded bottles on the top shelf. On the middle and bottom shelves, there appear to be other water bottle brands. From what I can observe, there appears to be a FIJI water bottle on one of the lower shelves (bottom shelf) mixed in with what looks like a different brand of water bottles. So yes, there appears to be a FIJI bottle on the wrong shelf.
Claude 4.1 Opus
Model answer: Looking at this refrigerated display case with water bottles, I can see what appears to be Fiji water bottles (with their distinctive square shape and blue labels) on multiple shelves, and possibly some other water brands. All the bottles appear to be water products appropriately placed in what looks like a water section of the cooler. I don't see any bottles that appear to be on the wrong shelf - they all seem to be water bottles in a water display area.
Cohere Aya Vision 32B
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. The brand of the bottle on the wrong shelf is Fiji.
Cohere Aya Vision 8B
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. The brand of the bottle on the wrong shelf appears to be Fiji Water.
GPT-4.1
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle on the wrong shelf. There is a Fiji bottle on the bottom shelf, which is otherwise stocked with Deer Park bottles.
GPT-4.1 Mini
Model answer: Yes, the brand "Poland Spring" is on the wrong shelf. It is placed on the shelf with "Fiji" bottles.
GPT-4.1 Nano
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. The bottles of Fiji water are on the wrong shelf; they are placed on the shelf with other bottled water brands.
GPT-5
Model answer: Fiji
GPT-5 (high reasoning)
Model answer: FIJI
GPT-5 Mini
Model answer: Fiji
GPT-5 with High Reasoning
Model answer: Fiji
Gemini 1.5 Flash
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. There are Fiji bottles on the bottom shelf.
Gemini 2.0 Flash
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. There are Fiji bottles on the bottom shelf.
Gemini 2.0 Flash Lite
Model answer: Yes, Fiji is on the wrong shelf.
Gemini 2.5 Flash
Model answer: Yes, there is a bottle on the wrong shelf. A **Fiji** water bottle is on the bottom shelf, which is otherwise stocked with Poland Spring water. Fiji water bottles are primarily on the top shelf.
Gemini 2.5 Flash Lite
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. The Fiji bottles are on the shelf with the Poland Spring bottles.
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Model answer: Yes, Fiji.
Gemma 3 27b
Model answer: Based on the image, **FIJI** bottles appear to be on the wrong shelf. The price tag visible on the bottom shelf indicates it is for "Dasani" or "Sparkling" water, while Fiji is a separate brand bottled water.
Llama 4 Maverick 17B
Model answer: No, there are no bottles on the wrong shelf. The image shows a fridge with three shelves, all containing bottles of Fiji and Poland Spring water. The bottles are neatly arranged and appear to be correctly placed on their respective shelves.
Llama 4 Scout 17B
Model answer: The image shows a refrigerator stocked with bottled water. The top shelf has Fiji water, the middle shelf has Poland Spring water, and the bottom shelf has Fiji water and Poland Spring water. The Fiji water on the bottom shelf appears to be on the wrong shelf.
OpenAI O1
Model answer: It looks as though there’s a single Fiji bottle placed among the green‐labeled bottles on the bottom shelf, so that Fiji bottle appears to be out of place.
OpenAI O3 (High Reasoning)
Model answer: Fiji
OpenAI O3 (Medium Reasoning)
Model answer: Fiji
OpenAI O4 Mini (High Reasoning)
Model answer: Yes. There’s a FIJI water bottle on the Poland Spring shelf.
OpenAI O4 Mini (Medium Reasoning)
Model answer: Yes. There’s a Fiji water bottle sitting on the Poland Spring shelf.
OpenAI o3-pro
Model answer: Fiji
Arcee.ai Spotlight
Model answer: No, there are no bottles on the wrong shelf in the image. All the bottles appear to be correctly placed according to their brand and type.
Claude 3.7 Sonnet
Model answer: From what I can see in the image, there don't appear to be any bottles on the wrong shelf. The refrigerator display shows several shelves of bottled water that seem to be properly organized. The bottles appear to be various brands of water, with similar types grouped together on each shelf. There's a price tag visible showing "$3" on one of the shelves. All bottles seem to be in their designated locations, and I don't notice any misplaced items or bottles that would be considered on the wrong shelf.
GPT-5 Nano
Model answer: No.
Gemini 1.5 Pro
Model answer: Yes. Deer Park.
Gemma 3 4B
Model answer: Yes, there is one bottle on the wrong shelf. The bottle labeled "Muji" is on the bottom shelf, which is designated for Sparkling Water.
Mistral Medium 3
Model answer: Yes, there are bottles on the wrong shelf. The "Spritz" brand bottles are placed on the middle shelf, which appears to be designated for a different type of bottle. The shelves seem to be organized by brand, and the "Spritz" bottles should likely be grouped with other "Spritz" bottles on the same shelf.
Mistral Small 3.1 24B
Model answer: Based on the image, it appears that the bottles are separated by size and type but not necessarily by brand. However, I don't see any clear indication that a specific brand is on the wrong shelf. The top shelf primarily contains larger blue water bottles, while the middle and bottom shelves have various smaller bottles of different brands, such as Poland Spring, Deja Blue, and other generic water bottles. Without additional context on how the shelves are supposed to be organized, I cannot definitively say that any specific brand, like Coca-Cola, is on the wrong shelf.
Phi 4 Multimodal
Model answer: yes
Qwen 2.5 VL 7B
Model answer: No, there are no bottles on the wrong shelf in this image. All the bottles are placed in their respective sections according to their brand and type. For example, the water bottles are grouped together, and there is no mixing of different brands on the same shelf.