How models perform on this prompt
ChatGPT-4o (High Reasoning)
Model answer: Yes, the metal plates in tray position 4 (the rightmost tray) have no blue parts on top. **Answer: 4**
ChatGPT-4o (Medium Reasoning)
Model answer: Yes, the metal plates in tray position 4 (the rightmost tray) have no blue parts on top. **Answer: 4**.
Claude 3.5 Haiku
Model answer: Let me carefully examine the image and count the trays from left to right: Tray 1 (leftmost): Has blue parts Tray 2: Has blue parts Tray 3: Has blue parts Tray 4 (rightmost): Has blue parts Since all trays have blue parts on top, the answer is NULL.
Claude 3.7 Sonnet
Model answer: Looking at the image, I can see an automated manufacturing or assembly line with metal trays/plates arranged in a row. There appear to be blue components or parts placed on some of the metal plates. Examining the trays from left to right: - The leftmost trays (positions 1, 2, 3) all appear to have blue components on top of them - The rightmost tray (position 4) appears to be empty with no blue parts visible on it Based on your question, since position 4 (the rightmost tray) appears to have no blue parts on top, my answer would be: 4
Claude 4 Opus
Model answer: Looking at the image, I can see 4 metal plates/trays arranged horizontally. Each tray appears to have blue components or parts on top of it: - Tray 1 (leftmost): Has blue parts - Tray 2: Has blue parts - Tray 3: Has blue parts - Tray 4 (rightmost): Has blue parts All metal plates visible in the image have blue parts on top of them. Therefore, there are no metal plates without blue parts. NULL
Claude 4 Sonnet
Model answer: Looking at the image, I can see 4 metal trays/plates arranged from left to right. Each tray appears to have blue components or parts placed on top of them. Examining each tray position: - Position 1 (leftmost): Has blue parts on top - Position 2: Has blue parts on top - Position 3: Has blue parts on top - Position 4 (rightmost): Has blue parts on top All four trays appear to have blue parts/components placed on them. Since there are no metal plates without blue parts on top, the answer is: NULL
Claude 4.1 Opus
Model answer: Looking at the image, I can see 4 metal plates/trays in a production line setup. Examining each tray from left to right: 1. Tray 1 (leftmost): Has blue components on top 2. Tray 2: Has blue components on top 3. Tray 3: Has blue components on top 4. Tray 4 (rightmost): Appears to be empty or has no blue parts on top Tray 4 (the rightmost tray) does not have blue parts on top. Answer: 4
Cohere Aya Vision 32B
Model answer: To determine if any metal plates have no blue parts on top and return the tray position, we need to analyze the image carefully. Here are the steps to follow: 1. **Identify the Metal Plates**: In the image, there are several metal plates arranged in a row. Each plate has a series of holes or cavities where blue parts are placed. 2. **Examine Each Plate**: Starting from the leftmost plate (tray 1) and moving to the rightmost plate (tray 4), inspect each plate to see if it has any blue parts in its cavities. 3. **Check for Empty Cavities**: If a plate has any cavities that do not contain blue parts, it meets the criteria. Note the position of this plate. 4. **Return the Position**: If a plate with empty cavities is found, return its position (1, 2, 3, or 4). If no such plate is found, return NULL. After carefully examining the image: - Tray 1: All cavities contain blue parts. - Tray 2: All cavities contain blue parts. - Tray 3: All cavities contain blue parts. - Tray 4: Some cavities do not contain blue parts. Therefore, the tray position that has no blue parts on top is **4**.
GPT-4.1
Model answer: Yes, there is a metal plate tray with no blue parts on top. The tray in position 4 (the rightmost tray) has no blue parts on top.
GPT-4.1 Mini
Model answer: The metal plates in tray position 4 (rightmost tray) have no blue parts on top.
GPT-4.1 Nano
Model answer: The metal plates on trays 1, 2, and 4 have blue parts on top. The metal plate on tray 3 has no blue parts on top. Therefore, the answer is: 3
GPT-5
Model answer: 4
GPT-5 (high reasoning)
Model answer: 4
GPT-5 Mini
Model answer: 4
GPT-5 with High Reasoning
Model answer: 4
Gemini 2.0 Flash
Model answer: Yes, the tray in position 4 has no blue parts on top. Therefore, the answer is 4.
Gemini 2.5 Flash
Model answer: Tray 4
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Model answer: 4
Gemma 3 27b
Model answer: Based on the provided image, it appears that **tray position 4** has metal plates with no visible blue parts on top. Therefore, the answer is **4**.
Gemma 3 4B
Model answer: Let's analyze the image to see if any metal plates have no blue parts. Looking at the image, I can see metal plates in four trays. The plates in trays 1, 2, 3, and 4 all have blue sections on top. Therefore, the answer is NULL.
Llama 4 Maverick 17B
Model answer: The image shows a machine with four metal plates. The first, second, third, and fourth plates from the left are all blue on top. * The first plate is blue. * The second plate is blue. * The third plate is blue. * The fourth plate is not visible in the image. Since all visible metal plates have blue parts on top, we need to check if there are any other plates that are not visible. Upon closer inspection of the image, it appears that there are four trays, and the fourth tray is empty. Therefore, the answer is: **4**
Llama 4 Scout 17B
Model answer: ## Step 1: Analyze the image The image shows a machine with various metal parts and wires. There are several metal plates or trays with blue parts on them. ## Step 2: Identify the trays There are four trays visible in the image, each with a series of small blue parts on top. ## Step 3: Check for trays with no blue parts Looking at the image, we can see that the tray at position 4 (the rightmost tray) has no blue parts on top. ## Step 4: Determine the position of the tray with no blue parts The tray with no blue parts is at position 4. The final answer is: $\boxed{4}$
Mistral Medium 3
Model answer: Based on the image, the four trays are positioned as follows from left to right: 1. Tray 1: Has blue parts on top. 2. Tray 2: Has blue parts on top. 3. Tray 3: Has blue parts on top. 4. Tray 4: Has blue parts on top. Since all trays have blue parts on top, the correct answer is: NULL
OpenAI O3 (High Reasoning)
Model answer: 4
OpenAI O3 (Medium Reasoning)
Model answer: 4
OpenAI O4 Mini (High Reasoning)
Model answer: 4
OpenAI O4 Mini (Medium Reasoning)
Model answer: Tray 4 has no blue parts on top.
OpenAI o3-pro
Model answer: 4
Arcee.ai Spotlight
Model answer: The image shows a machine with metal plates, some of which have blue parts on top. However, there are no metal plates that have no blue parts on top. Therefore, the answer is NULL.
Cohere Aya Vision 8B
Model answer: The image shows a complex industrial machine with various components, including metal plates and blue parts. However, there are no visible blue parts on top of any of the metal plates in the image. Therefore, the answer is NULL.
GPT-5 Nano
Model answer: NULL
Gemini 1.5 Flash
Model answer: NULL
Gemini 1.5 Pro
Model answer: Tray position 2 has no blue parts on top. Therefore, the answer is 2.
Gemini 2.0 Flash Lite
Model answer: Based on the image, all the metal plates appear to have blue parts on top. Therefore, the answer is NULL.
Gemini 2.5 Flash Lite
Model answer: 3
Mistral Small 3.1 24B
Model answer: In the image, all the metal plates in the trays have blue parts on top. Therefore, there is no tray position where a metal plate has no blue parts on top. The answer is: NULL.
OpenAI O1
Model answer: NULL
Phi 4 Multimodal
Model answer: 3
Qwen 2.5 VL 7B
Model answer: To determine if any metal plates have no blue parts on top, we need to analyze the image and identify the presence of blue parts on the metal plates. In the image: - The metal plates are located in the middle of the machine. - Each metal plate has blue parts on top of it. Since all the metal plates have blue parts on top, there are no metal plates with no blue parts on top. Therefore, the function should return `NULL`.